Crime Fiction Alphabet: B is for Bibliophiles

People who love books – whether it be reading. collecting. selling, loaning or repairing them – appear very frequently in crime fiction. I guess this is not terribly surprising given that a lot of crime fiction readers and writers are book lovers too. Many of the crime fiction novels featuring bibliophiles of one sort or another also pay homage to the early pioneers of the genre which is a bonus for new readers (it’s a great way to learn about the classics) as well as being fun for more knowledgeable fans who like to spot all the ‘inside baseball’ references.

English antiquarian bookseller Roy H Lewis is also an author with a book-selling hero, Matthew Coll. In the last of five novels in which he features, Death in Verona (1989), Coll travels to Italy to research earlier versions of the story of Lady Capulet which is incorporated into Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. When the local expert he has been working with is battered to death Coll becomes a suspect and when trying to clear himself encounters all manner of thugs and n’er do wells along with an Italian countess with whom romance blossoms.

Among his works the prolific Lawrence Block has a caper series set in New York featuring Bernie Rhodenbarr who has the dual occupations of bookseller and burglar. Block parodies Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None and other vintage crime tales in 1997′s The Burglar in the Library where Bernie is aiming to steal a Raymond Chandler first edition from a New England guest house but has to become an investigator of crimes rather than a perpetrator of them when guests start dropping like flies. Fans of classic crime will enjoy this one.

Helma Zukas is the librarian heroine of Jo Dereske’s series set in Washington (the state not the city). To offset the somewhat stereotypical characteristics of her profession Miss Zukas is often joined in sleuthing by her friend Ruth who is an avant-garde artist. In 2001′s Miss Zukas Shelves the Evidence the Chief of Police is nearly killed when investigating a murder and a library book is found near him. Police demand the borrower’s name but in an event that would these days be likely to see her end up in Guantanamo Bay Miss Zukas deletes the patron’s name from the library’s records rather than invade her client’s privacy.

Lorna Barrett’s series featuring Tricia Miles, who runs a New Hampshire bookstore called Haven’t Got A Clue with the assistance of her cat Miss Marple, started with 2008′s Murder is Binding. Tricia’s bookstore is on a whole street of bookstores selling different kinds of books and she comes under suspicion when the owner of the cookbook store is found stabbed to death and a rare book stolen. I love the notion of a whole street of bookstores, the only place I have ever seen such a phenomenon is Hay-On-Wye in Wales which I was lucky enough to visit once. Sigh.

Kate Carlisle has a relatively new cosy series featuring a rare book repairer, Brooklyn Wainright, in San Francisco. The author makes good use of the setting by giving Brooklyn parents who are members of a local commune and there are other quirky touches in this fun series. In the first book, Homicide in Hardcover (2009), Brooklyn is reunited with the man who first introduced her to book restoration but he is murdered later that evening, while clutching a rare copy of Goethe’s Faust which he was in the middle of restoring.

There are two comic crime fiction series set in Ireland which feature book lovers. Ian Sansom’s protagonist is Israel Armstrong whose job as a mobile librarian for Tumdrum and District Public Library while living in a reclaimed chicken coop doesn’t make for the glamorous life he imagined.  In the first book in the series, The Case of the Missing Books, Israel first has to recover the 15,000 books that have been…err…borrowed….by locals before he can start his new job properly. The series is very light and from the books I’ve read (Mr Dixon Disappears is the only one I’ve reviewed here) don’t even involve death. (Colin) Bateman’s series about the owner of crime fiction bookshop No Alibi starts with Mystery Man and is more of a satire of the genre. Although there are many other reasons to like the book I am particularly taken with the bookshop’s policy of operating a “James Patterson-free zone“.

Perhaps one of the best known, and certainly one of the longest running, series about a book lover is Carolyn Hart’s series featuring Annie Laurence, owner of the Death on Demand bookstore on a South Carolina island. In the first of 21 books in the series, 1987′s Death on Demand, Annie is hosting a regular gathering of famous mystery writers when one of them dies and she becomes a suspect in the murder. There are odes to crime fiction scattered throughout these books including Annie’s cat’s names (Agatha is one and I think  Dorothy another) and the monthly quiz run at the store which requires people to name mystery novels depicted in paintings displayed. I have reviewed Death of the Party, Dead Days of Summer and Dead Man’s Island.

Do you like reading crime fiction about books and book lovers? Can you recommend any others that I haven’t talked about here?

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Kerrie at Mysteries in Paradise is hosting the crime fiction alphabet meme which requires the posting of an article relating to the letter of the week (a book title, an author name, a subject…) Do join in the fun by reading the posts and/or contributing one of your own. You don’t have to write every week.

This is the second round of the meme which was first run from late 2009 to early 2010. My contributions that time were discussions of books with one word titles.

Review: Dead Man’s Island by Carolyn Hart

I have read the majority of Carolyn Hart’s more well-known Death on Demand series but being a sucker for ‘country house’ whodunnits I thought I’d give the first novel in her Henrie O series a shot.

Chase Prescott is a millionaire newspaper publisher who someone has tried to kill by poisoning some chocolate he was supposed to eat (but which killed the poor dog instead). In an effort to try to find out who the culprit was Prescott invites those members of his family and wider entourage who had the opportunity to poison him to his private island off the coast of South Carolina. In addition he asks his old friend, retired reporter Henrietta O’Dwyer Collins, to come along and work out who the potential murderer is. As if being stuck on an island with a pool of possible murderers isn’t quite enough there is also the threat of an impending hurricane.

As a classic whodunnit Dead Man’s Island works well with its interesting pool of suspects and red herrings a-plenty. Chase Prescott is deliberately unlikable (surely likable people wouldn’t have nearly as many people ready to kill them) and the various employees and family members surrounding him all have credible reasons for wanting him dead. The ultimate solution was quite clever. The additional thrills added by the increasingly bad weather are terrific; either Hart has been directly in the path of a terrible hurricane or she is impressively creative. I really felt like I was clinging on for dear life as bits of house were being whipped away by torrential rain and wind.

I thought I would like the character of Henrie O more than I did. I’m all for books featuring intelligent female characters who are over 30 but Henrie O was a bit too full of herself for me. In some ways she reminded me of the impossibly brilliant Amelia Peabody who features in Elizabeth Peters’ Egyptian series except I didn’t detect the necessary sense of humour. Unfortunately I just found Henire O had an over-inflated sense of her own intellect and abilities and I can’t imagine wanting to spend much time in her company.

Hart is a good writer of traditional mysteries and I’m sure my dislike of Henrie O is not universal so the series is worth giving a try if you’re looking for a cosy series with plenty of atmosphere.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

My rating 3/5
Publisher Bantam [1993]
ISBN 0553566075
Length 323 pages
Format mass market paperback
Source I mooched it

Review: Dead Days of Summer by Carolyn Hart

Title: Dead Days of Summer (the 17th Death on Demand mystery)

Author: Carolyn Hart

Publisher: William Morrow [2006]

ISBN: 0-06-072402-1

Length: 280 pages

Setting: America (South Carolina), present day

Genre: Cosy/amateur sleuth

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

My rating: 3/5

One-liner: Nicely-paced yarn about an innocent man’s arrest with a guaranteed happy ending

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Proprietor of the Death on Demand mystery bookstore Annie Darling is preoccupied with a secret: the surprise party she is planning her husband Max’s 29th birthday. Max is killing time at his office one afternoon when a new client walks in asking for his assistance in locating her missing brother. Max agrees to go with her to a seedy bar which is the last place the brother was seen but after doing so he wakes up in a strange cottage with no memory of the previous night’s events. The woman, who he was seen with my several witnesses, has been found dead and Max is covered in her blood. When he is arrested things look bleak but Annie and their circle of friends soon rally around to clear his name.

I’ve read quite a lot of the books in this series, the last being Death of the Party which I read last year and did not enjoy very much. However I needed something light that I could read while distracted* and picked this one from the bottom of my large TBR. Happily it turned out to be a much better read than the last book in the series. The romance element is still present but it was held in check this time round because Annie and Max spent most of the book separated from each other so there was a limit to the schmaltzy dialogue between the pair. I don’t mind seeing a couple in love but sometimes the way these two talk is a bit much.

The story kept up a good pace too and I am a bit of a sucker for a wronged-man yarn. I live in mortal fear of going to prison for something I didn’t do (for some people it’s heights for me it’s being locked up) and am always inclined to an emotional interest in stories that involve this kind of scenario. Max’s feelings of helplessness while incarcerated (even if only for a few days) were quite well depicted. The rallying of Max and Annie’s friends is charming but unrealistic and the resolution is quite predictable but if you’re in the mood for a well-paced and upbeat story you could do a lot worse than Dead Days of Summer.

*I had to spend a day in a series of noisy medical waiting rooms as I took my turn looking after an old family friend who has a lot of ailments and some books require less concentration than others.

Review: Death of the Party by Carolyn Hart

Title: Death of the Partydeath-of-the-party

Author: Carolyn Hart

Publisher: Avon (2006)

ISBN: 9780060004774

When Britt Barlow walks into Max Darling’s investigative agency and asks for his help snaring a murderer he urges her to go to the police. When she refuses Max, and his mystery book store owner wife Annie, head to Britt’s private island off the coast of South Carolina where she has arranged a weekend party to identify who murdered media magnate Jeremiah Addison on the island the previous year. The party guests, a few friends, family and colleagues of Addison’s, were all on the island at the time of his murder and Britt says one of them is the murderer.

The book is a variation on the house-full-of-possible-murderers story that’s been written many times before. It has a bunch of angst-ridden people with a range of guilty secrets: children angry with parents, wives who suspect their husbands and journalists prying into everything. The book is suspenseful enough, with false leads and red-herrings a-plenty, but offers nothing particularly unique and I suspect if you ask me a specific question about the it in a month or two I won’t be able to remember enough to answer you.

This is the 16th book in Hart’s Death on Demandseries, named for the bookshop run by Annie Darling, and the 9th I’ve read. I normally rather enjoy the references to mystery writers and crime fiction books that pepper the stories but this one didn’t contain many of those and it was also lacking the humour evident in the earlier novels. In fact I found the characters, including Annie and Max, a bit too schmaltzy and earnest for my liking on this outing.

Although they’re not my favourite kind of crime fiction I do like the occasional ‘cosy’ mystery for light relief after spending time with serial killers and brooding detectives but I think I’ll look elsewhere next time I’m in the mood for a light-hearted read.

My rating 2/5