Review: The Darkest Room by Johan Theorin

Johan Theorin’s first book was one of my top ten reads of last year so I didn’t need much incentive to settle down with his second novel, though being able to count it towards my 2010 Scandinavian Reading Challenge obligation and knowing it’s one of the four books I have left to read on the CWA International Dagger shortlist didn’t hurt.

Even though I read it alone and there wasn’t a campfire in sight reading The Darkest Room was a similar experience to having sat at the feet of an old-fashioned storyteller and become engrossed in his latest tale. Different threads and themes are woven together in a way that would be a disaster in a lesser craftsman’s hands but in Theorin’s, who is clearly a master of his craft, the sensitively translated product is deliciously atmospheric.

The novel centres on a house which was originally built from timber washed ashore after a shipwreck in 1846. The house, at Eel Point on the remote Swedish island of Öland, has seen many inhabitants in the subsequent decades and the book reveals what happened to some of them in between recounting the story of the house’s current owners Katrine and Joakim Westin. Just as they and their children are settling into their new home after moving from Stockholm tragedy strikes the family, as it has befallen many of the house’s previous occupants, and Theorin teases us by slowly revealing that things are not as they might first have seemed. Are there ghosts at Eel Point or does the danger that lurks take a more earthly form?

In addition to the Westins we meet Tilda Davidsson, a recently graduated police officer who is the sole officer operating full-time out of a newly re-opened station in one of the island’s towns. Her job is primarily a community liaison though she does have at least one more serious investigation to worry about as the island experiences a string of burglaries. As well as being an interesting character in her own right Tilda’s familial relationships offer a way for Theorin to include Gerlof Davidsson here, who was my favourite figure in the first book, Echoes from the Dead. There just aren’t enough clever octogenarians featured in fiction these days and even though Gerlof’s role is a more minor one I appreciated his insights as Tilda records his thoughts and stories in an informal oral history.

I know that saying that a book’s setting is a character is frowned upon in some reviewing circles but I can’t think of any other way to describe the presence in this story of the house in particular and the island in general. The action takes place in the Northern winter when the island is at its coldest, harshest and least inviting. Snow, ice and storms feature heavily and I can’t be the only reader to have reached for a warming cup of tea and another blanket as I lost myself in the tale. Aside from the natural environment the book also explores a theme that Theorin is clearly engaged by, namely the social changes the island has seen as Sweden has moved from being an agricultural based society to a more urbanised one.

There are plenty of other aspects of this absorbing book I could talk about but I’m wary of giving spoilers and frankly further discussion on my part is just taking you away from your next task which is to track down a copy of the book. Now. It is part historical fiction, part ghost story, part whodunit, and part sailor’s yarn. It is wholly enjoyable and recommended to all.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

My rating 5/5

Translator Marlaine Delargy; Publisher Black Swan [this edition 2010, original edition 2009]; ISBN 9780552774611; Length 474 pages

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Among the many places The Darkest Room has been reviewed are Crime Scraps*, CrimetimeEuroCrime, DJ’s Krimiblog, It’s A Crime (or a Mystery)* and Mysteries in Paradise (The reviews with an asterisk next to them are both quite lovely but they do give away a little more of the plot than I would like to have known before embarking on this particular book)

This entry was posted in book review, Johan Theorin, Scandinavian Reading Challenge 2010, Sweden. Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Review: The Darkest Room by Johan Theorin

  1. Norman says:

    Sorry about that Bernadette. I loved this book so much I got carried away and included too much in my plot summary. But I am pleased it got a 5 star review and we agree it is a brilliant book.


  2. Jose Ignacio says:

    Am currently reading it, so I will read your post once I finished mine. Glad you gave him 5/5.


  3. It was only a teensy thing Norman but I am super wary of spoilers lately, having been given almost the entire plot of a book I had planned to read in a ‘mainstream’ review – yours was not even close to that so no need to worry really


  4. Bernadette – I’d already planned to read this one, but after yours and Norman’s reviews, I now have absolutely no choice! I am looking forward to it.


  5. Maxine says:

    So glad you loved this book, Bernadette! It is one of the two I hope win the Int Dagger this year (the other is Hypothermia by Indridason) – hard to choose between them but on balance I would go for this one because it is such a rounded story, with so many threads and aspects. I loved it. Great review, thank you.


  6. Norman says:

    Maxine, we agree, but we are not the judges.


  7. Dorte H says:

    Even reviewers who don´t accept that a setting can be a character *must* accept that a house can! In this one it was both the house and the setting that added to the wonderful atmosphere.


  8. Pingback: the next Stieg Larsson « Scandinavian Crime Fiction

  9. Pingback: Halfway Down the Stairs | Reactions to Reading

  10. kathy durkin says:

    This is so good that I must read this and very soon. Another draw is the setting of cold, cold, cold, which I need because of the 102-degree temperature in the U.S. city I’m in. Would love to imagine the Nordic climes at this point. But this sounds like such a good book and I have to figure out how to get it without moving out of my a/c.
    Glad to see so many people liked it so much.


  11. Pingback: How do you say congratulations in Swedish? | Reactions to Reading

  12. Pingback: daggers, bankers, and science in crime fiction « Scandinavian Crime Fiction

  13. Pingback: And the winner is… | Reactions to Reading

  14. Pingback: OK you win (a Scandinavian Reading Challenge update) | Reactions to Reading

  15. Pingback: Books of the Month – June 2010 | Reactions to Reading

  16. Pingback: It’s a wrap on the Scandinavian Reading Challenge | Reactions to Reading

  17. Pingback: 2010 End of Year Book Survey | Reactions to Reading

  18. Pingback: 2010 – The Favourites | Reactions to Reading

  19. Pingback: The Darkest Room by Johan Theorin | The Game's Afoot

  20. Pingback: Review: The Quarry by Johan Theorin | Reactions to Reading

Comments are closed.