Review: THE POTTER’S FIELD by Andrea Camilleri

Although I haven’t read all the books in this series I have read enough of them to both know what to expect when opening the front cover of a new one and to eagerly anticipate my expectations being met. Happily I was not disappointed with the 13th instalment of the Inspector Salvo Montalbano series. At the centre of this book and its predecessors is an intelligent, introspective protagonist who loves good food, gives credence to his dreams and is in an unhappy struggle with the ageing process. Here he is called out to a rain-sodden crime scene where a body – or at least parts of one – has been discovered in a bin bag. When all the pieces of the poor individual have been collected it turns out to have been a middle-aged man but he is difficult to identify. As Montalbano grapples with the beginnings of the case several other troubles bubble to the surface including a beautiful woman reporting her husband missing and the behaviour of Montalbano’s faithful deputy Augello becomes increasingly erratic.

In its review of this novel Kirkus recommends the book for “mystery readers who enjoy the journey more than the solution” and I think that is a perfect description of who should read this book. The solution to the mystery is actually quite obvious from relatively early on but what kept my interest was watching how the case affected Montalbano and to see if things could be resolved so that those near and dear to him remained unhurt without causing lasting damage to Montalbano’s own integrity. And along the way there is the usual mixture of irascibility, good food and bad driving as well as some provided by the police station’s linguistically challenged desk sergeant and Montalbano’s own cynical side shining through such as when he muses that

Ingrid’s husband was a known ne’er-do-well, so it was only logical that he should turn to politics”.

Amongst all the gentle humour and stopping for long, delicious lunches there is some meat to the novel as it explores the nature of betrayal and its many guises. In turn this pushes the always philosophical Montalbano into consideration of more biblical references than I have seen him do in the past but they fit well into the story. In fact the only somewhat clunky cultural reference came from the self-referential scene in which Montalbano reads an Andrea Camilleri novel that turns out to have an indirect relevance to the case. This and the novel’s many purely slapstick moments prevented it from being the best of this series for me though perhaps these are the elements others look for.

Irrespective of any minor quibbles I thoroughly enjoyed THE POTTER’S FIELD which was, always, deftly translated by Steven Sartarelli whose notes at the end of each novel are almost as much of a treat as the story itself. It mixes humour and seriousness with ease and is just surreal enough to be surprising without stepping into absurd territory. Fans of the series won’t want to miss it though I probably wouldn’t recommend it as a starting point for people new to the series (its predecessor THE TRACK OF SAND would be a better place to start).

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

THE POTTER’S FIELD has been reviewed at Crime ScrapsMurder by Type and The Crime Segments

I have also reviewed August Heat, The Wings of the Sphinx and The Track of Sand

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
My rating 3.5/5
Translator Stephen Sartarelli
Publisher Penguin [this translation 2011, original edition 2008]
ISBN 9780143120131
Length 277 pages
Format paperback
Book Series #13 in the Inspector Montalbano series.
Source borrowed from the library

This entry was posted in Andrea Camilleri, book review, Italy. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Review: THE POTTER’S FIELD by Andrea Camilleri

  1. Kathy D. says:

    Good to read this. Reading about Salvo Montalbano is a treat and the wit is delicious. I do laugh out loud while reading these books.
    I just got an earlier book, Voice of the Violin, out of the library and eagerly look forward to reading it. I try to space these books out so I can look forward to reading one, but then I’ll have to start rereading them.


  2. Bernadette – Isn’t this a great series? I really like the “regulars” in it, including Montalbano himself, and I love the sense of humour woven through it as you mention although like you, I like the wry humour more than the slapstick stuff. I’m so glad you enjoyed this 🙂 and thanks for an excellent review.


  3. Maxine says:

    I haven’t read this one yet but am looking forward to it – I always enjoy these books, even the ones that are not quite up to standard. I think you’ve hit on most of the reasons why in your excellent review. In particular I agree that the Stephen Sartarelli notes are a delight – and having read some US and some UK editions, they are subtly different in each case. The sense of place conveyed in these books, taken as a whole, must be about the strongest in all of crime fiction?


  4. Kathy D. says:

    Omigosh, I forgot to also chime in about Stephen Sartarelli’s end notes, which are not only fascinating, but insightful and often hilarious. He apparently laughs out loud while translating these books.


  5. Kathy D. says:

    Just to say that I”m now 12 pages in to The Voice of the Violin and suddenly, I could feel the endorphins and serotonin kicking in, as well as if I were consuming delicious chocolate cake with tea. Camilleri should just bottle it and sell it! Now I can go to bed smiling.


  6. Pingback: Books of the Month – March 2012 | Reactions to Reading

  7. Pingback: International Dagger 2012 – Reading Progress and Speculation #1 | Reactions to Reading

  8. Pingback: Reseña: El campo del alfarero, de Andrea Camilleri | The Game's Afoot

  9. Pingback: International Dagger 2012 – Reading Progress and Speculation #2 | Reactions to Reading

  10. Pingback: International Dagger 2012 – Reading Progress and Speculation #3 | Reactions to Reading

  11. Pingback: Not a Review: THE AGE OF DOUBT by Andrea Camilleri | Reactions to Reading

Comments are closed.