#1955Book – Alan Hunter’s GENTLY DOES IT

I don’t think I’d ever heard of George Gently until the modern television series starring Martin Shaw in the title role started airing here and though I have warmed to the shows a little they didn’t make me want to rush for the source material. However I had some trouble finding a book first published in 1955 for this month’s classics challenge hosted by Past Offences so when I saw this title, which everyone agreed was definitely published in the right year, available cheaply as an eBook from an Australian store I grabbed it.

GentlyDoesItAlanHunter23308_fGENTLY DOES IT is the first of 48 novels to feature Inspector George Gently: a murder specialist from Central Office CID on holiday in Norchester for this novel. When he reads in the paper of the murder of a prominent local citizen he offers to help with the investigation. Initially his assistance is welcomed by the local constabulary but when it appears the case will be easily solved the locals are keen to remove Gently from proceedings. But Gently, believing in the innocence of the man local police suspect, refuses to be budged.

Perhaps low expectations are a good way to begin any reading experience because I did enjoy the book more than I thought I might, mostly due to the writing. Hunter, an antiquarian bookseller by trade, clearly loves language. Even his use of an adverb, and one not immediately associated with policing, for his protagonist’s surname indicates his love of wordplay. There’s a mild wit pervading the entire novel and the dialogue in particular is often delightful.

As far as introductions to a central character go however there’s something of a scarcity of information. We glean that he’s at least middle-aged, possibly older (in fact I would have thought much older if I hadn’t known there are so many books to come so perhaps he is one of those lucky fictional characters who don’t age at the same pace as the rest of us). He’s experienced and good at his job though quite modest, often attributing his deductive powers and sound reasoning to luck rather than the intelligence it so obviously is. But there is not a word about his personal life, other than a professed liking for fishing and an addiction to peppermint creams, or any details of the years that led to his present circumstances. With respect to looks Hunter gives us precious little to go on bar a throwaway remark that he’s not tall enough to enjoy the terraces at a football match so, inevitability, to me Inspector Gently looks a lot like Martin Shaw.

Via a Gentle Reminder To the Reader – which appears at the beginning of the novel – Alan Hunter tells us exactly what kind of story he thinks this is

This is a detective story, but not a ‘whodunnit’. Its aim is to give a picture of a police investigator slowly building up his knowledge of a crime to a point, not where he knows who did it – both you and he know that at a fairly early stage – but to a point where he can bring a charge which will convince a jury.

I thought it worth mentioning this. I hate being criticized for not doing what I had no intention of doing.

I might argue with him on whether or not it is a whodunnit (as the culprit is not revealed until about 3/4 of the way to the end) but even if it isn’t strictly a whodunnit you’d be hard-pressed to find a more traditional sort of mystery story. It closely follows the style of the Golden Age writers though I suppose it’s a bit too new to officially be classified as such. But other than the absence of a sidekick most of the conventions of the classic mystery are in evidence and well executed.

I don’t mind dabbling at the lighter/cosier end of the crime fiction spectrum (it was welcome in this instance as I’d read three or four particularly harrowing books in a row) but when I do I generally prefer there to be something in addition to the puzzling element of the stories. I follow one of Julie Hyzy’s series because of its setting amidst the goings-on of the White House kitchens for example. Alternatively I like re-visiting great characters who feel like old friends (M. Poirot springs to mind). But while Gently is likeable enough he’s not among the more memorable crime-fighting protagonists I’ve met and nor am I lured by yet another series set in Midsomer-like England.

I fear it’s damning with faint praise but I do think that if you like the classic British whodunnit-cum-procedural style of book then you could do a lot worse than GENTLY DOES IT. The writing is terrific and if it doesn’t leave you rolling on the floor with laughter you’ll at least have a smile on your face for a good portion of your reading time. A word of warning to fans of the TV series though: as far as I can see there is nothing other than the name of the main character that indicates one is the source material for the other though perhaps the later books have more in common with the series (which is set at least a decade or so later than this first novel).


This entry was posted in Alan Hunter, book review, England and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to #1955Book – Alan Hunter’s GENTLY DOES IT

  1. Bernadette – I know what you mean about wanting a little more substance to a character, even if the emphasis is on the mystery. I think our expectations are a little higher now. Still, it certainly sounds like a pleasant enough story. And I must admit I like that use of language.


  2. KerrieS says:

    I’ve read a couple of these Bernadette and have enjoyed them. I see them as a sort of forerunner to Ruth Rendell’s Wexfordseries, but also owing a bit to J.J. Marric’s Gideon books. I can’t help seeing Martin Shaw in my mind’s eye as Gently though


  3. Belle Wong says:

    I do sometimes get in the mood for a Golden-Age like mystery, and since I’m constantly listening to rereads of Agatha Christie in audio, there are times when I feel like a new-to-me traditional-style mystery would go down well. I know Christie wrote a lot of books, but it feels like I’ve reread them over and over so many times (probably because they’re my comfort reads and I like to have them in the background when I can’t sleep or when I’m working) and I too often remember whodunnit fairly early in the game. I’ll definitely have to check out this series.


    • I like listening to the Christie books too Belle – definitely a comfort factor there for me. I think the Gently books would be great in audio format – great dialogue always comes across well in the format – but I haven’t found any – at least not available to me.


  4. tracybham says:

    I haven’t tried an Inspector Gently novel in decades but I must have liked the ones I read, because I read more than one. But I do think I analyzed what I was reading much less when I was younger. Read more and was less discriminate. I go back and forth on what I want as far as knowing about the protagonist. I like the level of the Bill Slider mysteries by Cynthia Harrod-Eagles, where home life and background is definitely involved, but not too much (for me).


    • LOL Tracy I’m a bit the same – I like a bit of personal but not too much – probably very difficult to please. Have not tried the Bill Slider mysteries but sounds like I ought to


  5. When George Gently came on TV my husband (big TV detective fan) asked me if they were based on books, that being my area of expertise. I immediately said No, because I was sure that if there were books, I would know about them. It’s only quite recently that I found out I was wrong, they’d avoided my radar all that time, I was astonished that there could be a series of 48 about which I knew nothing! I found your review interesting, but it didn’t make me want to embark on this set of books…. so I am REALLY grateful! Last thing I need is that many more books to read….


  6. Thanks Bernadette – on your say so here I thought I’d give the Gently series a go and have GENTLY IN THE SUN (1958) on the shelf – it’s amazing that a series of books that ran for so long is so little known now.


  7. Bev Hankins says:

    I have yet to read this first Gently book, but I’ve read five of the series and even though I’ve given them mixed reviews it would seem that George Gently must have something that I like. Because I keep picking up more and more titles–I have three more on the TBR pile (including GENTLY IN THE SUN which Sergio mentions above). If you like what he does with language, I’d be interested in what you think of GENTLY GO MAN (should you ever decide to read it). He does something with the slang of the day….


    • I can actually see myself giving him another go Bev…I am a sucker for writing that plays with language in a funny or interesting way so I shall see if I can track that one down.


Comments are closed.